Another example of Edna
acting on impulse is when she decides to buy the “pigeon place.” She has the
idea and she immediately goes and buys it. This is the result of impulse not
free will. This article about free will as an illusion is very interesting and
it can be a claim for the actions of Edna. I think that Edna doesn't have those
intentions (adultery, neglecting her children, etc.) but other factors
contribute to her impulsive actions. This book reminds me a lot about the
Mexican culture. From what I have witnessed, I see women taking the role of a
housewife. They do not have a choice in either getting a job or being at home. The
man in the family decides that they will work to provide for the family and the
woman should take care of the house and the children. I know a family that
depends on these roles to be able to function as a family. What I mean is that
if the woman doesn't care for the children and the household chores, then the
house is out of order. I could say a lot about this aspect of the book and the
Mexican culture but I would be writing a book. The thing that surprised me the
most was the suicide issue. This book has so many issues that I think aren't appropriate
to teach in a high school class and it just comes to show that Huck Finn should
be acceptable in a high school setting.
Thursday, November 8, 2012
Free Will: The Awakening
While thinking about what I should write for
this post, I came across an article about free will. In class, we were talking
about Edna being free and having a privileged life that allowed her to neglect
her children because there would be someone to be the mother figure of her
children. Anyway, the article stated a claim: “free will is an illusion.” The article
also stated that “researchers have found patterns of brain activity that
predict people’s decisions up to 10 seconds before they’re aware they've made a
choice…The result was hard for some to stomach because it suggested that the
unconscious brain calls the shots, making free will an illusory afterthought.” Taking
this into consideration, I think that some of Edna’s actions could have been
impulsive. For example, when she decides to cheat on her husband it could have
been because she wasn't aware about her decision—like the article mentions. Free
will is defined as the ability to choose one’s actions or determine what
reasons are acceptable motivations for actions. According to the article, free
will is an illusion and I believe this is true in the actions of Edna because the
life that she is living with her husband and children has taken a toll on
finding herself which makes her act on impulse rather than free will.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think that the idea of Freewill in this novel is kind of oversimplified. I get the idea that most people believe that Edna is free simply because she has the ability to make her own decisions and that she finds the ability to break free from all that society has imposed on her. However, when I hear this, I get the impression that Edna is not really free. The reason I say Edna has no Freewill is because most of her decision are impulse decisions. She never really thinks things through and instead her desires and affections towards Robert and Alcee are the driving force behind her decision making. Whenever I read books such as this, it never ceases to amaze me how little freewill the protagonists show because they are driven by a force which exists outside of their control.
ReplyDeleteWhat I am really trying to say I this post is that I think Edna cannot have freewill because her decisions are driven by forces beyond her control.
Both of these are really interesting points, Ivan, especially your discussion of cultural differences. This raises an important issue: how does a culture function if,as you say, its house is out of order because a member doesn't do his or her job?
ReplyDelete