Hard Times by Charles Dickens is truly a classic novel. There
will also be turmoil between the rich and the poor: one aspect in society that
has been affected by this turmoil is education. Funding for education is facing
budget cuts affecting programs, teachers, and especially the students who
attend schools and participate in those programs. Schooling then differs
between the schools with more funding and schools with less. In Hard Times, readers
are exposed to a school where nothing but fact is taught. In the school there
is no room for imaginations, creativity or anything of the sort to run freely
through children’s minds. It becomes quite clear that only the wealthier
families are able to send their children to school, while the poor don’t have
any means to pay for it.
To a degree, this stands true in America today. One
particular part of the novel developed this thought. When Sissy is given the
opportunity to go to school—if she agrees to entirely rid herself of her past
life—she is left to feel subordinate to the other students in class. She comes
home one day and tells Louisa about her learning difficulties. Sissy then explains what Mr. M’Choakumchild
asked her: “‘National Prosperity. Now this classroom is a nation. And in this
nation, there are fifty millions of money. Isn’t this a prosperous nation, and
a’n’t you in a thriving state?” “I said I didn’t know. I thought I couldn’t know
whether it was a prosperous nation or not, and whether I was in a thriving
state or not, unless I knew who had got the money, and whether any of it was
mine. But that had nothing to do with it. It was not in the figure at all”
(Dickens 66). Sissy’s thoughts are similar to those of today.
Another aspect of the school in Hard Times is that school is
strict, lifeless and relies solely on information that can be explained through
science, math, etc. Although it seems farfetched, it is happening today in
subtle forms. Recess is being cut in grade school, art and music programs are
being cut in colleges and secondary schools and books that open the mind are
being banned. I recently watched an episode of “Avatar: The Last Airbender – The
Headband”. In this episode Aang, the Avatar, is attending a Fire Nation school
as someone else. Aang is a free spirit and realizes that the students in the
school are rigid and lack spontaneity. Aang realizes this is an issue to his
adolescent peers and decides to help them. The schooling in Hard Times is seen
and feared in today’s society as well.
That was a really good connection you made between Hard Times schooling system and the fire nation system in Avatar. When I was reading this book I was more focused on how bad I felt for the characters that I didn't really think about the educational system in it and it's connections to our modern day educational system; it was a really good parallel that I'm glad to know about now.
ReplyDeleteI’m glad you drew a connection between the education system in Hard Times and the education system today. Their schooling in the novel seems insane with how lifeless and fact-driven it is, but remnants of that exist in our schooling today. What you said about cutting music and arts programs is sad but true; there is also still an emphasis on memorization rather than comprehension in many schools and subject areas. The sad thing is that the characters and settings in this novel are clearly meant as caricatures, but that we can see the most extreme parts of them in our lives today is pretty shocking. You had some really great insight, and I’m glad you brought it up!
ReplyDeleteI agree with your point that school today is becoming much more focused on science and math as we struggle as a country to improve in those aspects of education. I wish, however, that you had discussed more of Sissy's upbringing. She did attend the school while still poor and living with her father. It is not until a bit later that she moves in with the Gradgrinds and experiences fully their way of life. What do you think of Sissy's upbringing? Do you think there is any correlation between her being raised on creativity and her eventual happy, content life in the end?
ReplyDelete